Topics & some posts of late... :-(
This was taken from a mate of mines forum and i wanted to put his post up here as well as i really think we have gone overboard on this forum in the last 6 months,i have been emceeing for the last 8...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
It's always been one of my bugbears but I have always stated there must be 100% accountability for official's performances in a boxing ring. The judges have a young man's careers in their hands on a...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
Zigsta wrote: phil austin wrote: I agree with you completely on my run-in with Ziggy, it is highly regrettable and something I wish I could re-visit so it would not have turned out like it did! I...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
phil austin wrote: Cheers Ziggy, glad you see it that way. Mate, no other way to see it! We both do things a little different to the 'Main Stream' person in our positions! You are an official, and you...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
Is it correct that within the Queensland ANBF, some judges favour quality of punches and some favour quantity (the number of) over quality (the harder punch)? I have seen some descrepencies in scoring...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
How can there be such an apathetic view about criteria. It is easy to do isnt it? to give up your time and watch vidios together and discuss scoring and discover and agree on a common method and...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
we discuss scoring each month at the meetings and have held seminars as well, many who officiate on an international level have attended seminars through their governing bodies too
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
Heres a question,some judges have an issue me reading out the judges names at some fights boxing and non boxing. For example they dont like me saying, popeye had 48-47 red corner, grinna had it 47-48...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
have always believed the crowd have the right to know who scored it what way
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
Yeah,,I'm a bit each way on that Perry. As Phil said, the crowd have a right to know. On the other hand, a hot head whose boy lost the decision may well react in the heat of the moment. However,...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
the corner is going to find out from the supervisor anyway, it's a moot point IMO
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
Hi Perry, Where it is "controversial" or a split decision the judges scores and names should be read out...as it builds the tension... but for normal scores "The winner by unanimous decision....."...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
good luck getting guys to protest that had it go their way Damo. You are right though, all contentious decisions should be protested rather than just complained about so things can be done. Lodge a...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
Over here I have been doing Trial cards and now judging for around 1 year. We have already done 2 officials workshops. Which covers scoring, Rules, Regs etc I don't think that every judge will ever be...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
I agree with you Ben that every judge will see sometings differently, especially in close rounds, but what I am talking about is judges that use totally different criteria to get a result at the end...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
I don't think a minority of judges really think of the impact of not being impartial. I've seen some pretty dodgy decisions with little hope of justification, but the was a trace, however how can the...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
Damien , I only ever read out the judges scorecard it is really close such as a split decision to sell the drama as they say,i do really like the implementation on big K-1 Shows where after each round...
View ArticleRe: Topics & some posts of late... :-(
WBC figured it would be a great idea to announce scores after each 3 rounds @ the last annual convention to give it transparency. When they sobered up, they figured it was a SHITE idea
View Article
